Novels (Sign of Four / Study in Scarlet) vs The Fantasy Hall of Fame [22 stories] — Which Should You Read First?

Both Novels (Sign of Four / Study in Scarlet) and The Fantasy Hall of Fame [22 stories] are beloved by readers. Here is what RateYourReads readers say about both, plus similar books you might enjoy.

• The case of the smoking chimney by Erle Stanley Gardner
• Saturn's Children by Charles Stross
• The Blue Fairy Book by Andrew Lang
• A Rare Benedictine by Edith Pargeter
• Théâtre complet by Alexandre Dumas
• Buffalo gals, won't you come out tonight by Ursula K. Le Guin
• Novels (Emma / Pride and Prejudice / Sense and Sensibility) by Jane Austen
• The Adventure of the Blue Carbuncle by Arthur Conan Doyle