The fifth child vs Mama's nightingale — Which Should You Read First?

Both The fifth child and Mama's nightingale are beloved by readers. Here is what RateYourReads readers say about both, plus similar books you might enjoy.

• Short Stories (Gold-Bug / Purloined Letter) by Edgar Allan Poe
• The crown of wild olives by John Ruskin
• Words are my matter by Ursula K. Le Guin
• The old beauty by Willa Cather
• The Midnight Line by Lee Child
• A Kiss Before Dying by Ira Levin
• Martin Guerre by Alexandre Dumas
• Detective stories by Philip Pullman